Hi everyone. This is my first time on any forum so apologies if I’ve not been able to find a similar post that’s already been answered.
I was just wondering if any of you ladies out there had any experience of MS and taking HRT while going through perimenopause? I was diagnosed with MS 27 years ago when I was in my mid 20s. My consultant at the time was the epitome of optimism but my husband remembers him saying words along the lines of, ‘Watch out for menopause. Oestrogen levels are under suspicion about how they can affect MS as you get older; consider looking into HRT’. Many years on, and now in secondary progressive and peri-menopausal, I am wondering if anyone has any experience of HRT having either positive or negative effects? I have had conflicting opinions from two consultants, one who said there might be benefits and one who shrugged his shoulders and said he couldn’t see why it would help but speak to your GP. I seem to be getting away with peri-menopause relatively easily (famous last words!), so don’t feel the need for HRT - unless it would possibly delay any further progression.
Sorry for the long ramble but any thoughts would be gratefully received.
I’m mid-60s now, and I find HRT extremely helpful. My neurologist shrugged and said ‘no idea’ as well, but that’s doctors for you – no interest in anything outside their specialist area. Which is a bit annoying, actually, given that half their MS patients probably more than half are women and they will go through menopause, so it sort of IS his specialist area, but there you go.
I remember reading something that Prof Gavin Giovannoni wrote about MS and menopause and oestrogen. A Google search would probably take you there.
1 Like
Hi Alison. Thanks so much for your reply, that’s very helpful. I’ll certainly see if I can find Prof Giovannoni’s paper as I need any info I can to help me decide what to do. It is so frustrating when the experts don’t have any answers for something that should be basic advice for older women MS patients. I think many are nervous these days to express their own opinion in case of possible complaint or litigation. I was hoping for informed advice but three separate neurologists over the years have had no opinion other than to point me in the direction of my GP, who, understandably, has no experience of HRT in relation to MS.
Can I ask, do you feel the HRT is beneficial to your MS symptoms directly, or just your path through menopause? Has it affected your relapse rate, or have you seen any improvement in your symptoms?
Thanks so much again for your time and advice.
1 Like
I think it’s probably one of those area where there just isn’t very much very strong evidence, and it’s down to us to make up our minds as best we can. No use waiting for the experts to opine - we’re busy women and life is happening now. In good truth, I think more medicine is like that than we like to suppose.
Your question about how HRT has helped my MS is a good one but I don’t have a good answer. In terms of relapses, while I’ve been on HRT I haven’t had any, but I put that down to the natalizumab that I have been on for many years. Past MS damage makes me inclined to fall over a lot, and I’m very lightly-built, so I do value HRT’s protective effect on bones. And I also appreciate the general absence of aches and pains that seem to afflict my contemporaries more than they affect me, even though I have had MS for 25+ years and most of them don’t have it. I sleep well, have no vasomotor symptoms of menopause, have no trouble maintaining a normal weight, get as much healthy exercise as MS constraints allow, my joints are in good nick. How much of that would be the case without HRT? No idea, and I can’t run a control experiment in a parallel universe to find out. But I won’t be in a hurry to give up the HRT, that’s for sure.
Thanks so much for your thoughts, Alison. It is such a difficult decision because, as you point out, it is so difficult to work out whether any identified health benefits or improvements are the medication we all have to take or the HRT. I will have to keep doing my homework and try and make a decision as to whether to give it a go. I think my husband thinks that the HRT will set me back to where I was 10 years ago, but I am under no illusion of the path I am now on.
Thanks so much again for taking the time to reply to me. Very best wishes to you keeping as healthy as you can long into the future.
1 Like
I think with MS and menopause and all the rest of it, I’m inclined to go for marginal gains wherever I can find them.