Forum

Echinacea

Hi,

Has anyone ever heard of ‘Echinacea’ being a Bad treatment for us MSers pls? Wondered as I av a heavy cold right now, in the past (before MS); I used to be a huge believer in the healing powers of Homeopathic remedies and used to use this as a treatment. Someone on the MS boards told me that us MSers, shouldn’t be using anything that encourages our immune systems to get stronger, as more Myelin will be killed off in our brains.

Anyone got any info on this pls?

I ty in advance for all replies,

Tc

Anna x

Hi Anna,

Yes, definitely - I won’t touch it!

Then again I may be the original poster who said this, so backing up my own argument probably doesn’t really count.

Echinacea is purportedly immune boosting. People with MS don’t have a weakened immune system, and if anything should avoid pumping it up.

If you are talking ONLY about homeopathic remedies, my personal belief is that as they are diluted to the extent of having NO active ingredient, they will neither help nor harm you. So I suppose it couldn’t hurt to take a homeopathic preparation of echinacea. In my opinion, you’d be wasting your time and money, but if you sincerely believe in it, I suppose you might get some benefit from the placebo effect.

Then again, if you really believe it does do something, you would presumably believe it is revving up your immune system, and that would not be a good thing for MS, so would the hope of benefit outweigh the worry that you might be doing harm?

For something as short-term as a cold, which usually only lasts a few days anyway, I definitely wouldn’t think it’s worth dabbling with anything that even might give the MS a little boost.

If it were me, I’d stick to paracetamol, and the most adventurous DIY remedy I’d try would be rum-and-black, which, as far as I know, isn’t contraindicated with MS.

Hope you feel better soon.

Tina

x

3 Likes

Hi Tina,

Ty for the info and advice hun…

Will try the Rum n Black approach next i think lol :wink:

:slight_smile:

Tc

Anna x

I asked my then-neurologist about this way back when newly dx. I still smile when I remember the withering look that accompanied his very firm assurance that it wouldn’t make the slightest bit of difference one way or the other. :slight_smile:

Alison

Years ago I thought perhaps taking echinacea in the winter would help ward off colds. Instead all I got was numb hands, feet and tingling face. Went away when I stopped. Tried again the following winter , exactly the same. Mentioned it to my gp who immediately said not to take it, asked neurologist who also said people with Ms shouldn’t take it. It definitely makes my symptoms much worse.